Skip to content
ContentLora

    Tip: press / anywhere to search.

    Analysis

    Loot box regulation in 2026: ban, label or leave it to industry?

    As of October 2026, loot box rules are diverging: Brazil bans them in games likely used by minors,[1][2] Europe's PEGI now rates most games that sell them PEGI 16,[3][4] and the US relies on self-regulation backed by FTC enforcement.[5][6] The debate turns on how strong the gambling evidence is and whether industry measures have worked.[7][8]

    Editor reviewedUpdated GamingTech policy
    Show:

    This page is about policy, not legal advice. It sets out what each jurisdiction has done as of 10 October 2026 and the main arguments.

    Where the rules stand

    Brazil has gone furthest of the jurisdictions covered here. Law 15.211 of 17 September 2025 prohibits loot boxes in electronic games aimed at children and adolescents or likely to be accessed by them, and it took effect on 17 March 2026.[1][2]

    Europe works mainly through age ratings. From June 2026 PEGI rates new games with paid random items PEGI 16 by default, and PEGI 18 in some cases.[3] On 6 October 2026 PEGI said it had begun raising digital-only games rated PEGI 3, 7 or 12 that contain loot boxes to PEGI 16.[4] As of July 2026, EU regulators were reported to be considering an outright ban on loot boxes in games accessible to minors under the proposed Digital Fairness Act.[9]

    The United Kingdom decided in 2022 not to change the Gambling Act, concluding that most loot boxes fall outside the legal definition of gambling because prizes cannot be cashed out.[10][11] Its stated view is that children should not be able to buy loot boxes without parental approval, to be delivered by industry-led measures.[12]

    The United States relies on industry self-regulation.[5] The ESRB labels games with paid random items.[13] Enforcement has come through consumer-protection law: in January 2025 Genshin Impact’s maker agreed to a $20 million settlement with the FTC that blocks under-16s from in-game purchases without parental consent and bars selling loot boxes only through virtual currency.[6][14]

    Beyond loot boxes: other regulated mechanics

    PEGI’s 2026 criteria reach past loot boxes to other mechanics. Time-limited or quantity-limited offers lead to PEGI 12, and NFT or blockchain mechanics to PEGI 18.[15] Rewards for returning to a game, such as daily quests, lead to PEGI 7, and penalties for not returning to PEGI 12.[16] Germany’s USK, which adopted similar criteria in 2023, said at least one criterion applied to about 30% of submitted games, and about one in three of those received a higher rating.[17]

    Simulated gambling is handled separately. In February 2025 PEGI’s Complaints Board cut the poker-themed deck-builder Balatro from PEGI 18 to PEGI 12 on appeal.[18]

    The shift is from labelling individual purchases to rating the design of the whole game. A PEGI 16 rating on a game children already play affects store visibility and parental controls far more than a purchase notice does, which is why the October 2026 re-rating of existing games is the bigger practical change.[4] If the USK experience carries over, a meaningful minority of European releases could see higher ratings, though PEGI has not published its own figures yet.[17]

    The evidence question

    A 2018 survey of 7,422 gamers found that loot box spending was linked to problem gambling severity, more strongly than other in-game spending was.[19][20] Its authors said it could not tell whether loot boxes lead to problem gambling or whether problem gamblers are drawn to loot boxes.[7] On compliance, a 2025 paper by Leon Xiao found that none of the UK’s top 100 highest-grossing iPhone games sought parental consent before letting minors buy loot boxes.[8]

    Both sides can point to the same evidence. A consistent correlation without established causation supports precautionary rules for children, but it is weaker support for treating loot boxes as gambling for adults. The UK compliance finding is a direct test of the industry-led approach the UK chose in 2022, and it weakens the case that voluntary measures are enough.[11][8]

    The money at stake

    Chance-based mechanics like loot boxes generated about $23 billion worldwide in 2025, according to S&P data.[21] Industry group Video Games Europe has argued that disproportionate legislation would disrupt legitimate business models and harm competitiveness and consumer choice.[22]

    The direction of travel points to more age-gating, not less. Watch three things: whether the EU’s Digital Fairness Act includes a minors’ ban when it is tabled, which was reported as expected in 2027;[9] how Brazil enforces its ban in practice; and whether publishers redesign games globally to avoid a PEGI 16 rating instead of changing them region by region. These are open questions, not predictions.

    Competing views

    Ban sales to minors

    Loot boxes resemble gambling, research has found a link with problem gambling, and self-regulation has not delivered parental consent in practice. Brazil-style bans and the proposed EU Digital Fairness Act take this line.[19][8][1][9]

    Label, rate and enforce existing law

    Age ratings, purchase labels and consumer-protection enforcement against deceptive odds can address the harms without banning a business model. PEGI's 2026 criteria and the FTC's Genshin Impact order are examples.[3][14][13]

    Let industry lead

    The evidence does not show loot boxes cause gambling problems, most do not meet legal definitions of gambling, and heavy regulation would disrupt legitimate business models and consumer choice.[7][10][22]

    Questions readers ask

    Are loot boxes banned anywhere?

    Brazil's Law 15.211 bans loot boxes in electronic games aimed at or likely to be accessed by children and adolescents, effective 17 March 2026.[1][2]

    Is the EU banning loot boxes?

    Not yet. As of July 2026, EU regulators were reported to be considering a ban on loot boxes in games accessible to minors under the proposed Digital Fairness Act.[9]

    What did the FTC do about Genshin Impact?

    In January 2025 the game's maker agreed to pay $20 million and block under-16s from purchases without parental consent, and was barred from selling loot boxes only through virtual currency.[6][14]

    Why did the UK not ban loot boxes?

    In 2022 the government concluded most loot boxes are not gambling under the Gambling Act, because prizes stay in the game, and chose industry-led protections instead of new law.[10][11]

    Do other mechanics besides loot boxes affect ratings?

    Yes. PEGI's 2026 criteria also rate time-limited offers at PEGI 12, NFT or blockchain mechanics at PEGI 18, and daily-return rewards at PEGI 7 or 12.[15][16]

    Sources

    Each numbered claim is a statement we checked against the sources listed with it. Status shows how well established it is.

    1. [1]

      Brazil's Law 15.211 of 17 September 2025, the Digital Statute of Children and Adolescents, prohibits loot boxes in electronic games aimed at or likely to be accessed by children and adolescents. confirmedas of 2025-09-17

    2. [2]

      Brazil's Law 15.211 took effect on 17 March 2026. confirmedas of 2026-03-17

    3. [3]

      Under PEGI's 2026 criteria, a game containing paid random items gets a default rating of PEGI 16, and in some cases PEGI 18. confirmedas of 2026-03-12

    4. [4]

      Starting in October 2026, PEGI began re-rating digital-only games rated PEGI 3, 7 or 12 that contain paid random items such as loot boxes, raising them to PEGI 16. confirmedas of 2026-10-06

    5. [5]

      As of July 2026 the United States relied on the games industry to self-regulate loot boxes. reportedas of 2026-07-04

    6. [6]

      In January 2025 the maker of Genshin Impact agreed to pay $20 million and to block children under 16 from in-game purchases without parental consent to settle FTC allegations. confirmedas of 2025-01-17

    7. [7]

      The authors of the 2018 PLOS ONE survey said it was unclear whether buying loot boxes leads to problem gambling or whether problem gamblers are drawn to spend heavily on loot boxes. confirmedas of 2018-11-21

    8. [8]

      A 2025 paper by Leon Xiao found that none of the UK's top 100 highest-grossing iPhone games sought parental consent before letting minors buy loot boxes. reportedas of 2026-07-04

    9. [9]

      As of July 2026, EU regulators were considering an outright ban on loot boxes in games accessible to minors under the proposed Digital Fairness Act, which was expected to pass in 2027. reportedas of 2026-07-04

    10. [10]

      The UK government said in 2022 that most loot boxes do not meet the legal definition of gambling under the Gambling Act 2005, because prizes stay in the game and cannot be converted into real money. confirmedas of 2026-10-10

    11. [11]

      The UK government decided in 2022 not to change the Gambling Act or other statutory consumer protections for loot boxes, preferring industry-led measures first. confirmedas of 2026-10-10

    12. [12]

      The UK government's view is that children and young people should not be able to buy loot boxes without parental approval. confirmedas of 2026-10-10

    13. [13]

      In April 2020 the ESRB introduced an "In-Game Purchases (Includes Random Items)" notice for games that sell randomised items, including loot boxes, gacha, item or card packs, prize wheels and treasure chests. confirmedas of 2020-04-13

    14. [14]

      The FTC's proposed order against Genshin Impact's maker barred it from selling loot boxes through virtual currency without also offering a direct real-money purchase option. confirmedas of 2025-01-17

    15. [15]

      Under PEGI's 2026 criteria, games with time-limited or quantity-limited offers are rated PEGI 12, and games with NFTs or blockchain mechanisms are rated PEGI 18. confirmedas of 2026-03-12

    16. [16]

      Under PEGI's 2026 criteria, mechanics that reward returning to a game, such as daily quests, lead to at least PEGI 7, and mechanics that punish players for not returning lead to PEGI 12. confirmedas of 2026-03-12

    17. [17]

      Germany's USK said that after it adopted similar criteria in 2023, at least one new criterion applied to about 30% of submitted games and about one in three of those received a higher age rating. confirmedas of 2026-03-12

    18. [18]

      In February 2025 PEGI's Complaints Board changed the deck-building game Balatro from PEGI 18 to PEGI 12 after an appeal by its publisher. confirmedas of 2025-02-24

    19. [20]

      In the 2018 PLOS ONE survey, the link between problem gambling and loot box spending was stronger than the link between problem gambling and spending on other in-game items. confirmedas of 2018-11-21

    20. [21]

      According to S&P research data reported by Bloomberg, chance-based mechanics such as loot boxes generated about $23 billion for video game companies worldwide in 2025. reportedas of 2026-07-04

    21. [22]

      Industry group Video Games Europe argued that disproportionate legislation would disrupt legitimate business models and hurt the sector's competitiveness and consumer choice. reportedas of 2026-07-04

    Revision history (1)
    1. Page created.

    Created Oct 10, 2026. Last reviewed by an editor on Oct 10, 2026. Next scheduled review: Jan 10, 2027.

    Cite this page

    "Loot box regulation in 2026: ban, label or leave it to industry?." ContentLora, updated Oct 10, 2026. https://contentlora.com/analysis/loot-box-regulation-debate

    Spotted an error? Suggest a correction or emailcorrections@contentlora.com.

    Keep exploring

    ☰ Contents