Skip to content
ContentLora

    Tip: press / anywhere to search.

    Explainer

    First Choice Women's Resource Centers v. Davenport (Platkin)

    First Choice Women's Resource Centers v. Davenport, earlier filed against attorney general Matthew Platkin, is the Supreme Court's unanimous April 29, 2026 ruling that a New Jersey pregnancy center could challenge the state attorney general's subpoena for its donors' names in federal court.[1][2] The Court held that the demand caused a present injury to the group's First Amendment associational rights, giving it standing to sue now rather than after a state court ordered compliance.[1][3] It reversed the Third Circuit and sent the case back.[4]

    Editor reviewedStrict sourcingUpdated Explainer10 claims · 100% primaryCourts and the law, Pregnancy and reproductive health

    This explainer describes the case from the Supreme Court’s opinion, published by Cornell’s Legal Information Institute, and the Court’s question-presented page. The state’s accusations are described only as the Court recorded them. It does not assess the ruling, the group or the state’s investigation. Checked at 2026-11-14 (UTC).

    First Choice Women’s Resource Centers v. Davenport asked when a group served with a state subpoena for its donors’ names can go to federal court. On April 29, 2026, a unanimous Supreme Court held that the demand itself caused a present injury to the group’s First Amendment associational rights, so it had standing to sue.[1] The respondent is New Jersey’s attorney general. The Court’s docket records a brief in opposition filed by respondent Matthew Platkin, and the opinion calls the demand “Mr. Platkin’s subpoena”; the case is now captioned against Jennifer Davenport.[2]

    The subpoena

    First Choice is a religious nonprofit that has provided counseling and resources to pregnant women in New Jersey since 1985 and does not provide or refer for abortions.[5] According to the Court, New Jersey’s attorney general set up a Reproductive Rights Strike Force in 2022. It served First Choice with a subpoena for 28 categories of documents, including the names and contact details of donors who gave other than through one specific webpage.[6] As the Court’s syllabus describes it, the strike force had issued a consumer alert accusing groups like First Choice of providing false or misleading abortion information.[7] State abortion rules are covered in abortion laws explained.

    How the case reached the Court

    First Choice sued in federal court. The district court dismissed the suit, holding that First Choice had no injury, and so no standing, until a state court ordered it to comply; a divided Third Circuit panel affirmed.[3] The Supreme Court granted review on June 16, 2025, on whether a federal court in a first-filed case loses jurisdiction because the First Amendment rights at stake must be decided in state court.[8] It heard argument on December 2, 2025.[1]

    What the Court held

    Justice Gorsuch wrote for a unanimous Court.[1] It reasoned that official demands for a charity’s private donor information discourage association not only when enforced, but as soon as they are made and for as long as they remain outstanding.[9] It rejected the attorney general’s three arguments: that the subpoena was not self-executing, that donors could still give anonymously through one website, and that a state-court protective order could keep the documents confidential.[10]

    What the ruling leaves open

    The holding was about standing: whether First Choice could bring its challenge in federal court now.[1][8] The Court reversed the Third Circuit and remanded the case.[4] The free-speech and association background is covered in the First Amendment explained.

    Courts and the law: a crash course

    A sourced crash course on US courts and law: the Supreme Court, its 2026-27 term, federal rulemaking, Section 230, and the AI copyright and antitrust cases.

    Questions readers ask

    What did the Supreme Court decide in First Choice v. Davenport?

    On April 29, 2026, a unanimous Court held that First Choice had shown a present injury to its First Amendment associational rights, giving it standing to challenge the subpoena in federal court.[1]

    Why is the case called both Davenport and Platkin?

    The respondent is New Jersey's attorney general. The Court's docket records a brief in opposition filed by respondent Matthew Platkin, and the opinion calls the demand "Mr. Platkin's subpoena". The case is now captioned against Jennifer Davenport.[2]

    What did the subpoena demand?

    According to the Court, it demanded 28 categories of documents, including the names and contact details of donors who gave other than through one specific webpage.[6]

    Did the Court decide whether the subpoena is unconstitutional?

    The question it decided was standing, meaning whether First Choice could sue in federal court now. It reversed the Third Circuit and remanded the case.[1][8][4]

    What arguments did the Court reject?

    It rejected all three of the attorney general's arguments, namely that the subpoena was not self-executing, that donors could still give anonymously through one website, and that a state-court protective order could keep the documents confidential.[10]

    Sources

    · 10 claims from 2 publishers

    Each numbered claim is a statement we checked against the sources listed with it. Tap a number in the text to see its sources in place.

    1. [1]

      In First Choice Women's Resource Centers, Inc. v. Davenport (No. 24-781), argued December 2, 2025 and decided April 29, 2026, a unanimous Supreme Court held that First Choice had shown a present injury to its First Amendment associational rights, giving it standing to sue in federal court. confirmedas of 2026-11-14

    2. [2]

      The respondent is New Jersey's attorney general: the case is now captioned against Jennifer Davenport, the Court's docket records a brief in opposition filed by respondent Matthew Platkin, and the opinion calls the subpoena 'Mr. Platkin's subpoena'. confirmedas of 2026-11-14

    3. [3]

      The district court dismissed First Choice's federal suit, holding it had no injury, and so no standing, until a state court ordered it to comply; a divided Third Circuit panel affirmed. confirmedas of 2026-11-14

    4. [4]

      The Court reversed the Third Circuit and remanded the case. confirmedas of 2026-11-14

    5. [5]

      First Choice is a religious nonprofit that has provided counseling and resources to pregnant women in New Jersey since 1985 and does not provide or refer for abortions. confirmedas of 2026-11-14

    6. [6]

      According to the Court, New Jersey's attorney general set up a Reproductive Rights Strike Force in 2022 and served First Choice with a subpoena for 28 categories of documents, including the names and contact details of donors who gave other than through one specific webpage. confirmedas of 2026-11-14

    7. [7]

      The strike force issued a consumer alert accusing groups like First Choice of providing false or misleading abortion information, as the Court's syllabus describes it. confirmedas of 2026-11-14

    8. [8]

      The Supreme Court granted review on June 16, 2025, on whether a federal court in a first-filed action loses jurisdiction because the First Amendment rights at stake must be decided in state court. confirmedas of 2026-11-14

    9. [9]

      The Court reasoned that official demands for a charity's private donor information discourage association not only when enforced but as soon as they are made and for as long as they remain outstanding. confirmedas of 2026-11-14

    10. [10]

      The Court rejected the attorney general's three arguments: that the subpoena was not self-executing, that donors could still give anonymously through one website, and that a state-court protective order could keep the documents confidential. confirmedas of 2026-11-14

    Revision history (1)
    1. Page created.

    Created Nov 14, 2026. Last reviewed by an editor on Nov 15, 2026. Next scheduled review: Nov 17, 2027.

    Cite this page

    "First Choice Women's Resource Centers v. Davenport (Platkin)." ContentLora, updated Nov 14, 2026. https://contentlora.com/explain/first-choice-womens-resources-v-platkin-explained

    Spotted an error? Suggest a correction or emailcorrections@contentlora.com.